
Through her role as executive director of the Middletown Community Foundation—and a career marked by meaningful achievements—Sarah Nathan, Ph.D. ’13, has made an impact that earned her the 2025 Distinguished Alumni Award —an honor she did not anticipate. “I have a quieter approach to my work,” Nathan said. “To be recognized and know others are paying attention is gratifying.”
She describes her three-person team at the foundation as “small but mighty.” With a small staff, Nathan wears many hats—from serving as the chief fundraiser to managing daily operations. Her ultimate goal is to strengthen community and promote generosity in Middletown, Ohio and its surrounding communities.
It’s work that fills her with pride. “The part of the job that brings me the most joy is working with generous people, donors and families who really love this community,” she said. “This is a community that has a lot of challenges, but it’s clear that people really love this community and it shows through their generosity.”
The community entrusts the foundation to steward its resources responsibly, supporting free public events, educational initiatives, and evolving needs. Nathan has seen firsthand how the foundation’s funding turns vision into reality. For instance, the foundation provided seed money for a local high school to launch an eSports team. A teacher wanted to create a space for students not drawn to traditional athletics or the arts. Outside of gaming, these students now do other activities together such as going on college visits—proving that it’s about more than just gaming; it’s about belonging.
Her journey to the field of philanthropy didn’t take a direct route. As a college student, she didn’t know what career she wanted—only that she wasn’t interested in “just selling widgets.” While studying history and political science at Concordia College in Moorhead, Minnesota, she worked in the alumni office, calling graduates to ask for annual gifts and staying on during the summer.
“It was a formative experience,” she recalled. “I witnessed fundraising and alumni engagement up close.” That experience led her to seek roles in national nonprofits, taking her to Washington, D.C., and later back to her alma mater.
She later decided to pursue graduate studies. “When I found out about philanthropic studies, I realized it was the formal study of the work I’d already been doing but hadn’t had a vocabulary for,” she said. During a campus visit to Indianapolis, a suggestion by Philanthropic Studies Librarian Dr. Fran Huehls to take a walk cemented her decision. “We walked from the library to White River State Park, and the downtown skyline came into view. I thought, ‘I can live here.’ It was everything I hoped for in a graduate school.”
Nathan earned her master’s degree in 2009 and her Ph.D. in 2013, aiming to become an educator. In 2015, she joined the IU Lilly Family School of Philanthropy as associate director of The Fund Raising School. “It was the perfect fit—it combined my desire to teach with my field experience,” she said. “The best part is seeing participants immediately apply what they’ve learned.”



